高级检索

243颗根管再治疗患牙的诊治与分析

Analysis of diagnosis and treatment for 243 teeth involved with initial root canal treatment

  • 摘要: 目的: 探讨拆除根管充填物后根管再治疗的疗效,分析影响再治疗疗效的因素。方法: 选择2011年1月—2012年10月221例首次根管治疗失败后进行再治疗的患者,总计243颗患牙。依据X线标准及临床常见医源性因素将243颗患牙分为4组。A组:根管欠填;B组:根管漏充填;C组:根管超填且根尖有透射区;D组:根管充填不密合。为了进一步了解非医源性因素对根管再治疗的影响,再将243颗患牙按照年龄、牙位、根管是否通畅进行分类。采用临床症状及X线片进行疗效评价。结果: 243颗患牙根管再治疗成功222颗,成功率为91.36%。A、B、C、D组成功率分别为93.45%(157/168)、91.67%(22/24)、56.25%(9/16)、97.14%(34/35)。在非医源性因素中,根管通畅和根管欠通畅的再治疗成功率分别为96.49%(165/171)、79.17%(57/72),差异有统计学意义(P< 0.05);年龄≥60岁和年龄< 60岁的成功率分别为89.47%(136/152)、94.51%(86/91),差异无统计学意义;前牙和后牙的成功率分别为93.75%(105/112)、89.31%(117/131),差异无统计学意义。结论: 根管再治疗能取得较好疗效,但根管超填的失败率很高;根管是否通畅是影响再治疗成功的重要因素。

     

    Abstract: Objective: To explore the efficacy of root canal retreatment after the removal of root canal filling, and analyze the factors associated with efficacy. Methods: A total of 243 teeth from 221 patients, who underwent root canal retreatment after failure of initial root canal treatment during Jan. 2011 to Oct. 2012, were selected. According to X-ray criteria and iatrogenic factors, the 243 teeth were divided into four groups, root canal underfilling (group A), missing filling(group B), overfilling with apical radiolucent area (group C), loose filling (group D). In order to evaluate the effect of non-iatrogenic factors on root canal retreatment, the 243 teeth were divided again by age, teeth location, and root canal patency. The clinical symptom and X-ray examination was used to evaluate the efficacy. Results: Among the 243 teeth, 222 received successful root canal retreatment, and the success rate was 91.36%. The success rates were 93.45%(157/168), 91.67%(22/24), 56.25%(9/16), 97.14%(34/35)in group A, B, C, and D, respectively. According to non-iatrogenic factors, the success rates of root canal retreatment were 96.49%(165/171), 79.17%(57/72) in the cases with root canal patency and impatency, respectively, and there was significant difference between them (P< 0.05). And the success rate of patients age≥60 and < 60 years were 89.47%(136/152), 94.51%(86/91), respectively, and there was no significant difference between them. Furthermore, the success rate of front tooth and back tooth were 93.75%(105/112), 89.31%(117/131), respectively, and there was no significant difference between them. Conclusions: Root canal retreatment can obtain good curative effect. However, there is high failure rate in case of root canal overfilling. Whether root canal is patency or not is a great factor of success.

     

/

返回文章
返回