高级检索

新型国产双极射频消融仪的安全性和有效性离体实验

Ex vivo experiment on the safety and efficacy of a new domestic bipolar radiofrequency ablation generator

  • 摘要:
    目的  评估新型国产超高频双极射频消融仪的安全性和有效性。
    方法 以6个新鲜尸体脊柱腰椎标本为实验对象,采用新型国产超高频双极射频消融仪进行髓核消融和纤维环烧灼。髓核消融:取L1~L4共18个椎间盘,随机分为6组,经椎间孔侧方将射频电极穿入椎间盘,用50 W、75 W、100 W功率分别消融1 min、2 min,观察髓核消融情况,记录消融范围。纤维环烧灼:取L4~S1共12个椎间盘,按烧灼时间3 s、10 s或15 s随机分为3组,在37 ℃水浴恒温环境中,分别采用20 W、30 W、40 W功率进行烧灼,通过硬组织切片后苏木精-伊红染色,观察烧灼的深度和周围软组织的碳化情况。
    结果 消融1 min和2 min,髓核在50 W功率下均未见明显气化腔,100 W功率2 min组的消融面积最大(7.471±0.365)mm2, P<0.001。消融前后纤维环4个部位温度升高的程度均小于0.5 ℃。20 W各时间组烧灼深度显著低于30 W和40 W(P<0.01),但30 W与40 W组间差异无统计学意义;20 W组内3 s烧灼深度显著低于10 s和15 s(P<0.01);30 W与40 W组不同烧灼时间亚组间差异无统计学意义。30 W功率下烧灼3 s即可达到有效烧灼深度。
    结论 离体实验显示新型国产双极射频消融仪具有良好的消融效能和安全性参数,髓核消融建议100 W消融2 min,纤维环烧灼成形建议30 W烧灼3 s,其临床应用价值有待进一步体内研究验证。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective  To evaluate the safety and efficacy of a new domestic ultra-high frequency bipolar radiofrequency ablation device.
    Methods Six fresh cadaveric lumbar spine specimens were used as experimental subjects, and a novel domestic ultra-high frequency bipolar radiofrequency ablation device was employed for nucleus pulposus ablation and annulus fibrosus cauterization. Nucleus pulposus ablation: a total of 18 intervertebral discs from L1 to L4 were selected and randomly divided into six groups. Radiofrequency electrodes were inserted into the intervertebral discs through the lateral aspect of the intervertebral foramen, and the ablation was performed at power outputs of 50 W, 75 W, and 100 W for 1 min and 2 min, respectively. The ablation of the nucleus pulposus was observed, and the ablation range was recorded. Annulus fibrosus cauterization: a total of 12 intervertebral discs from L4 to S1 were divided into three groups based on cauterization duration of 3 s, 10 s, or 15 s. In a water bath maintained at a constant 37 °C, cauterization was performed at power outputs of 20 W, 30 W, and 40 W, respectively. After hard tissue sectioning and hematoxylin and eosin (HE) staining, the depth of cauterization and the carbonization of surrounding soft tissues were observed.
    Results No obvious vaporization cavity was observed in the nucleus pulposus at a power of 50 W for either 1 or 2 min. The 100 W–2 min group achieved the largest ablation area (7.471±0.365 mm2, P<0.001). The temperature elevation at all four annulus fibrosus sites remained below 0.5℃ throughout the ablation process. The cauterization depth in the 20 W group was significantly lower than that in both the 30 W and 40 W groups across all time conditions (P<0.01), whereas no statistically significant difference was observed between the latter two. In 20 W group, the cauterization depth at 3 s was significantly lower than that of the 10 s and 15 s groups (P<0.01). No significant intra-group differences were found among subgroups with different cauterization durations in the 30 W and 40 W groups. An effective cauterization depth was already achieved at 30 W for 3 s.
    Conclusions Ex vivo experiments have shown that the new domestic bipolar radiofrequency ablation device possesses excellent ablation efficacy and safety parameters. For nucleus pulposus ablation, it is recommended to use 100 W for 2 min, while for annulus fibrosus cauterization and shaping, 30 W for 3 s is suggested. Its clinical application value remains to be further verified through in vivo studies.

     

/

返回文章
返回